Dupuytrens and Ledderhose Disease
A Radiotherapy Treatment Experience
Written August 2019 – a patient’s review
I am a 68 year old New Zealand male with a long history of Dupuytrens disease (palmar
fibromatosis) and Ledderhose disease (plantar fibromatosis). I have detailed my experiences
in this article in the hope that it may give other sufferers of these diseases some insight into
the use of radiotherapy as a form of treatment. I documented my treatment period
(2018/2019) with photos, notes and measurements and have used these as the basis for
this report. I have tried to be accurate and practical with my assessments and hope I have
struck the right balance in the content. This article reflects my own journey and private
opinions, based on my research and experiences.
Dupuytrens overview.
I have a family history of Dupuytrens and I first noticed I had early symptoms of the disease
back in the mid 1980’s. These symptoms slowly progressed over the years, with signs of
thickening skin, followed by nodes, cords and finally contractures of the fingers. During the
period 1996 to 2013 I had 4 surgeries (2 on each hand) for Dupuytrens. As my hand
surgeon noted, I have quite an aggressive form of the disease. The surgeries addressed the
various nodes, cords and contractures in the palms, index and small fingers and in the webs
of both hands. One of the procedures was a revision surgery with a large, full thickness skin
graft to my right little finger.
In the period 2013 through to 2018 the disease progressed noticeably in both my left and
right hands. In both hands there were nodes in some fingers, thickened areas of skin, cords,
lumps developing in the webs between thumb and forefinger and also the beginnings of
contracture to some fingers. By mid 2018 it was obvious that another operation on my left
hand was going to be necessary at sometime in the next couple of years and that the right
hand would also need future surgery. Obviously I was not looking forward to the pain, risk,
cost, or the 8 to 12 week recovery periods. I will come back to Dupuytrens later in the article.
Ledderhose overview.
I probably noticed the first signs of Ledderhose in my feet about the same time as I noticed
the Dupuytrens forming – in the mid 1980’s. These signs presented as: a 10mm diameter
lump along the arch of each foot, midway between the ball of the foot and heel, and on the
left foot there was an additional 10mm lump just below the ball of the foot. Over 30 years
these lumps changed very little and caused no problems at all - although I noticed the very
slow development of 2 extra lumps along the arch of both feet.
Catalyst for Change.
In early 2018 I noticed that the minor lumps in both feet seemed to be getting bigger. By mid
2018 it was obvious that I had 2 to 3 rapidly increasing lumps in each foot and the increases
in size were clearly noticeable with each passing month. These were beginning to cause
regular pain when standing or walking and they frequently caused a sharp aching sensation,
even when my feet were elevated. These distressing developments, coupled with the
ongoing Dupuytrens symptoms I mentioned above, were the catalyst for some serious
research. My previous experience and reading indicated that for both Dupuytrens and
Ledderhose disease the most common treatments were surgical.
I already had extensive experience with Dupuytrens surgeries - all successfully performed
with no complications but with a reoccurence of the disease guaranteed.
I discussed the Ledderhose situation with my GP and underwent both ultrasound and then
MRI scans to confirm the extent of the condition (and to confirm that the diagnosis was
correct). Subsequently I was referred to a specialist orthopaedic foot surgeon for
examination and consultation. Essentially the specialist’s written assessment was that my
only option was to wait until the disease became debilitating and then to have surgery. He
specifically noted that there were no proven alternative treatments.
My reading had indicated that this disease is know to reappear aggressively after surgery in
approx 80% of cases. The level and degree of recommended surgery to minimise
reoccurrence is, in my opinion, horrific. My interpretation of the medical terminology is that it
involves removing the skin from the soles of the feet and replacing with a skin graft. I
considered the side effects of this procedure would dramatically affect my lifestyle –
basically, severely limiting my mobility. This was not a surgery that I was prepared to
consider.
Treatment Options.
I began researching alternative treatments for Dupuytrens and Ledderhose disease. Among
them I considered collagenase injections, shockwave therapy, steroid injections and
radiotherapy. In my opinion the two medical conditions are essentially the same disease,
presenting differently in different parts of the body and I was hoping to find a common
treatment for both conditions.
Treatment Objectives
My first, and major objective was to halt the progression of the disease - thus avoiding or
postponing the need for immediate surgery. The second was to slow or prevent a
re-occurrence of symptoms. The third objective was to reduce the effect of these conditions
in some practical way - perhaps by reducing the size of lumps, nodes, etc, or perhaps
reducing the degree of contraction in fingers or toes, or by simply softening the skin on
palms or soles.
Extensive reading and research revealed that radiotherapy would likely achieve my major
objective and that the second and third objectives could be considered reasonable as an
expected outcome. The internet provided a wealth of information – although it took some
months for me to reach my conclusion that radiotherapy was the right option.
In late August 2018 I began an independent search for a treatment provider by directly
approaching private radiotherapy clinics and specialists across New Zealand. My situation
and prospects were such that I was also prepared to travel to either the UK, Australia or
Germany if necessary.
I received a positive response from Dr Ramesh Arunachalam, Consultant Radiation
Oncologist at the Auckland Radiation Oncologist Specialist Centre. Dr Arunachalam already
had experience in treating Dupuytrens and Ledderhose and he agreed to treat me. He gave
me clear guidelines as to the most probable outcomes of the radiotherapy and detailed the
procedures along with a few possible minor side effects – seemingly, the worst being the
possibility of long term dry skin. He did note that radiotherapy is not normally useful in a
situation where contractures have already developed.
The radiotherapy would involve treating the cords and nodules with a 20mm margin to a
dose of 30GY in 10 treatments. This would be done via a split course where 15GY is
delivered as 3GY each day for 5 consecutive days. This procedure is repeated after a break
of 6 – 8 weeks.
The plan was to treat my feet first and to review the results 12 weeks after completion of the
radiotherapy, with a plan to then schedule the same treatment for my hands.
Ledderhose Treatment.
Treatment was scheduled to begin in late September 2018. The week before treatment
began I visited the hospital for approx 2 hours so that some custom shaped, sheet-lead,
shields could be made to protect the areas outside the radiation target zones. At each
radiation session these were taped across my hands (total set up time of approx 5 mins per
hand). The radiation delivery was 2.5 minutes per hand – the machine was silent and the
procedure completely free of any discomfort or sensations. It was actually difficult to believe
anything was happening. Each visit took a total of approx 25-30min.
By the start of treatment I had 3 lumps in my left foot measuring 35x45mm, 18mm diameter
and 12mm diameter respectively. The largest had developed in just 18 months from approx.
10mm diameter. In the right foot there were 2 lumps measuring 32x38mm and 18x12mm
respectively. These had grown at a similar scale and rate as the left foot. Additionally a
noticeable tightness had developed in the tendons along the soles - decreasing flexibility on
extension.
Ledderhose RT Results
It took about 3 weeks for the effects of the first round of treatment to be clearly noticed and
this was generally evidenced as a reduction in size and a softening of the lumps. The skin
did become dry and I applied moisturiser twice daily. The effects slowly continued over the 8
weeks leading up to the second round of radiotherapy. I viewed these initial results as very
positive.
The second round was completed and within 2 weeks the effects were really beginning to
show with a steady reduction in the size of all lumps. The discomfort experienced on walking,
standing and at rest was consistently reducing, and the hard cords which had been
developing along the soles of both feet had softened and become more flexible, allowing the
feet to extend freely when walking.
I cannot express the sense of excitement and relief that I felt by late January 2019. This had
been a hugely successful result – far beyond the conservative expectations I had at the
beginning of the treatment.
Dr Arunachalam reviewed my situation at the end of January. His observations can be
summarised: “Post treatment the patient has had a dramatic response to RT with all his
lesions in both feet showing significant reduction in size. In fact, on examination it is very
difficult to feel the smaller nodules”.
I had experienced minimal side effects during treatment apart from some mild skin irritation
and some tenderness. These symptoms had resolved within 2 weeks of the last RT session
– in fact I spent several weeks of last summer barefooted on a boat and at the beach.
It has become apparent to me that the positive effects of the RT continue for several months
after the treatments end.
As I write this article in August 2019, nearly 9 months since the
treatment ended I can summarise my situation.
I do have a single residual lump in each foot, each measuring approx 20x22mm. They are
quite flat and not particularly noticeable although they can be felt. There is no discomfort
when pressure is applied. The soles of both feet are more flexible and the cords softer and
less prominent.
Overall I feel that my Ledderhose symptoms have been reduced by approx
85%. I can walk, stand and run without any discomfort and essentially, on a normal daily
basis, I am completely unaware of the minor residual indications of the condition. In this
sense I can positively rate the RT treatment as a total success.
Whilst the long term efficacy of the RT is not completely known I believe I can optimistically
expect to remain untroubled by Ledderhose disease for at least several years – likely even
longer. If the condition should reoccur, my specialist advises that a further round of RT
treatment is considered both safe and practical.
Dupuytrens Treatment.
The first treatment was at the end of February 2019. At this time, in my right hand, I had a
noticeable cord running from the palm to base of the thumb where there were the beginnings
of 2 small nodes. These indications were accompanied by the usual thickening in the
surrounding skin. There was also a large 10mmx15mm sized lump in the web of the hand.
There were early signs of 2 nodes on my little finger (which had been skin grafted in 2000).
The Dupuytrens in my left hand was more advanced. The skin around the base of the thumb
had thickened and there was a knotted cord running from the palm, up the index finger to a
9mm diameter node just below the first joint. There was a large lump measuring approx
10x15x20mm in the web between thumb and forefinger and this caused some restriction to
my ability to fully open the gap between thumb and forefinger, and pain on over extension.
At the base of the little finger there was an area of noticeably thickened skin measuring
approx 20mmx20mm, and from here were 2 cords running up to an 8mm diameter node just
below the second joint. These were causing the early stages of contracture.
The preparations for treatment and the treatment regime for my hands were the same as for
the Ledderhose procedure.
Dupuytrens RT Results.
Again it took about 2 weeks for the effects of the first round of treatment to be clearly noticed
and this was generally evidenced as a softening of the harder areas of skin. The skin did
become dry and I applied moisturiser twice daily which controlled the condition. The effects
slowly continued over the 7 weeks leading up to the second round of radiotherapy. By this
time some of the lumps had reduced (although not as obviously as with the large
Ledderhose lumps) and the restriction between left thumb and forefinger had eased.
I viewed these as very positive initial results.
The second round was completed and within 2 weeks the effects were really beginning to
show with a steady reduction in the size of the lumps in the webs of both hands – both were
about 30% smaller. There was a further easing in the restriction between thumb and
forefinger on my left hand which allowed greater extension with reduced discomfort. The
large palm thickening at the base of the small finger was significantly reduced in volume with
the surrounding skin becoming soft and flexible to the touch. At this stage the 2 nodes on
this hand were little affected but there seemed to be a slight softening of the cords in the
little finger (an unexpected benefit – although small).
The changes in my right hand followed a similar course but I was pleased to see that the 2
small early stage nodes on the little finger had noticeably reduced.
At the 5 week point both hands began to dry and the skin deeply peeled in varying degrees
over most of the treated areas of both hands but particularly where there had been lumps.
This was great as it further reduced the apparent size of the lumps. It took about 3 weeks for
this process to complete and after that my hands were generally left softer and the skin more
flexible, although still somewhat dry – a condition easily remedied with moisturiser.
As with the Ledderhose experience, the positive effects of the RT continue for several
months after the treatments end. As I write this article in August 2019, nearly seven months
since the Dupuytrens treatment ended I can summarise my situation.
The lump in the web of my left hand has reduced by 60% in volume and that in the right by
80%. I have no noticeable restriction between thumb and forefinger of the left hand; full
extension and lifting a load cause no pain. My little finger is less contracted (it is now almost
straight). Nodes in the 2 fingers have reduced by about 20%. Areas of thickened and harder
skin are all approx. 50% reduced in size and softer. The cord running from palm to index
finger is mainly unchanged but subjectively a little more flexible.
The right hand has
continued to follow a similar improvement with the cord mainly unchanged but both nodes
in the little finger are now visually indistinguishable.
An interesting observation for me now is just how much the Dupuytrens growth seemed to
have been more generally spread across the surface layers of the skin on the palms of both
hands than I had noticed. The treatment has left the cords in both hands more noticeable to
the touch (I guess since the surface layers are now softer and more flexible).
Overall the results were very positive and although not as dramatic as those for the
Ledderhose I would say that all 3 of my initial expectations regarding RT were exceeded.
My main hope that the disease progression could be slowed or halted appears to have been
realistic and there is good evidence that Dupuytrens responds in this way to RT.
I would rate treatment as approx 60% successful in terms of a physical reduction in
symptoms but since the residual symptoms are essentially untroubling and visually
insignificant this success might well be considered around 75%.
I am therefore feeling positive that my Dupuytrens progression has been halted - certainly
the symptoms I was experiencing have significantly reduced. Although, as with the
Ledderhose, there are still some residual physical indicators, generally on a daily basis I
would say that I am now unaffected by the disease.
Summary.
At the start of this article I laid out the objectives I had for any treatment. The first was to halt
the progression of the disease - thus avoiding or postponing the need for immediate surgery.
The second was to slow or prevent re-occurrence of symptoms. The third objective was to
reduce the effect of these conditions in some practical way - perhaps by reducing the size of
lumps, nodes, etc or perhaps reducing the degree of contraction in fingers or toes or by
simply softening the skin on palms or soles. The ratings I have given the 2 treatments are
based on my original objectives and conservative expectations.
For me, the radiotherapy treatments I underwent in late 2018 and early 2019 have been
hugely successful in delivering significant improvements to the physical symptoms of the
diseases, and a corresponding reduction in the mental anxiety that is a real part of watching
the progression of these distressing conditions. I have no ongoing side effects or skin
dryness issues.
This time last year all I could see ahead of me was a round of aggressive foot surgeries
which would surely have left me significantly less mobile, if not partially disabled, and a
future of more routine surgeries to control the Dupuytrens. As I write this report I feel a great
sense of excitement at the very real and positive results of RT and look forward to the
strong probability this has halted the progression of the diseases – maybe not forever, but
I’ve read a lot of articles and reports which record no noticeable reoccurence of symptoms
for periods of more than 6-8 years.
My understanding is that RT is acknowledged to work best if treatment is given when either
Dupuytrens or Ledderhose are in the active growing phase, rather than after cords and
contractures have formed. To me this implies that treatment is better sooner than later and
that allowing the conditions to progress to advanced stages of growth and contracture (ie to
the degree where surgical intervention is normally considered and recommended) would
negate the very real benefits that early RT could bring.
I was advised that there is no risk of damage to underlying tendons or bone and studies
have suggested no increased complications with surgery after RT delivered to this dose – if
future surgery is needed.
From my experience I would urge those who suffer from Dupuytrens disease (palmar
fibromatosis) or Ledderhose disease (plantar fibromatosis) to seriously consider the early
intervention of Radiotherapy ahead of regular surgical procedures. If your regular GP or
surgical specialist is unfamiliar with, or unsupportive of, the use of RT for these conditions I
would urge you to “start the conversation” and, if possible, gain their support. If this is not
forthcoming then “self refer’ to a Radiotherapy Specialist.
I hope there are readers who have found this article useful – good luck with your quest.
Thanks to Dr Ramesh Arunachalam and to the kind, talented RT team who treated me at Auckland Hospital.
Disclaimer: This article is the result of my private research and personal experiences – I do not have a medical background.
Readers should form their own opinions about RT treatment and ultimately seek advice from a suitable medical professional.
.png)
